Let us know which books like Things We Never Got Over we missed!
“There’s a difference between taking care of someone because you love them and taking care of someone because you want them to love you.”
Nothing hits quite like the small-town charm, slow-burn tension, and grumpy/sunshine banter of Lucy Score’s Things We Never Got Over. If you’ve already torn through the Knockemout series and find yourself missing Knox and Naomi’s fiery dynamic – or just craving another fiercely protective hero who melts for the right woman – you’re not alone. The best news is that you don’t have to stay in that reading slump. Whether you’re hooked on the found-family warmth of a tightly-knit community, high-stakes emotional baggage, or swoon-worthy forced proximity, there is a whole shelf of contemporary romances ready to fill that Knockemout-sized hole in your heart. We’ve rounded up the absolute best books like Things We Never Got Over that serve up the same blend of humour, heart, and heat. So, grab your TBR list – your next five-star small-town obsession is waiting below.
Naomi wasn’t just running away from her wedding. She was riding to the rescue of her estranged twin to Knockemout, Virginia, a rough-around-the-edges town where disputes are settled the old-fashioned way. Too bad for Naomi, her evil twin sister hasn’t changed at all. After helping herself to Naomi’s car and cash, Tina leaves her with something unexpected. The niece Naomi never knew she had.
There’s a reason Knox doesn’t do complications or high-maintenance women, especially not the romantic ones. But since Naomi’s life imploded right in front of him, the least he can do is help her out of her jam. And as soon as she stops getting into new trouble, he can leave her alone and get back to his peaceful solitary life. At least, that’s the plan until the trouble turns into danger.
Check Out Our Guide On How To Read The Knockemout Books In Order
First up on our list of books like Things We Never Got Over is Paige Toon’s second-chance bestseller, What If I Never Get Over You. Ellie never expected to fall in love while interrailing through Europe. But she also didn’t expect a man like Ash. Three blistering days in Lisbon is all it takes to form an unforgettable connection – a bond deep enough to scrap their itineraries and plan to meet again in Spain. But Ellie arrives late, and Ash never shows.
Six years on, Ellie has landed her dream job working as a gardener for a viscount and viscountess on their sprawling five-hundred-year-old estate in Wales. She finds peace amongst the towering topiary hedges and colourful gardens, yet her idyll is shattered when Ash crashes back into her life. And when it becomes clear why he didn’t show in Madrid, her heart breaks anew – for what the truth means for their fate.
When Shay Zucconi’s step-grandmother died, she left Shay a tulip farm – under two conditions. First, Shay has to move home to the small town of Friendship, Rhode Island. Second – and most problematic, since her fiancé just called off the wedding – Shay needs to be married within one year. Marriage is the last thing in the world Shay wants, but she’ll do anything to save the one real home she’s ever known.
Noah Barden loved Shay back in high school. Not that he ever told her. He was too shy, too awkward, too painfully uncool to ask out the beautiful, popular girl. A lifetime later, Noah is a single dad to his niece and has his hands full running the family business. That old crush is the farthest thing from his mind. Until Shay returns to their hometown.
Losing people you love is tough. Aurora De La Torre knows moving back to a place that was once home isn’t going to be easy. Starting your whole life over probably isn’t supposed to be. But a small town in the mountains may be the perfect remedy for a broken heart. Checking out her landlord across the driveway may just cure it too.
Piper Bellinger is fashionable, influential, and her reputation as a wild child means the paparazzi are constantly on her heels. Her stepfather decides that enough is enough; he cuts her off and sends Piper and her sister to learn some responsibility running their late father’s dive bar in Washington. She hasn’t even been in Westport for five minutes before she runs into big, bearded sea captain Brendan. Yet she’s determined to show everyone that she’s more than just a pretty face.
The fun-loving socialite and gruff fisherman are polar opposites, but there’s an undeniable attraction simmering between them. Piper doesn’t want any distractions, especially feelings for a man who sails into the sunset for weeks at a time. But as she reconnects with her past and begins to feel at home, Piper begins to wonder if the cold, glamorous life she is living is what she truly wants.
Check Out The Best Books Like It Happened One Summer
Calla Fletcher was two when her mother took her and fled the Alaskan wild, unable to handle the isolation and left behind Calla’s father, Wren Fletcher. Calla never looked back. Now twenty-six, her busy life in Toronto is all she knows. But when her father reaches out to tell her his days are numbered, Calla knows it’s time to make the long trip back to the remote frontier town where she was born.
While she struggles to adjust to this new subarctic environment, Jonah – the quiet, brooding and proud Alaskan pilot who keeps her father’s charter plane company operation – can’t imagine anywhere else as home. He thinks she isn’t cut out for the wild. She’s determined to prove him wrong. And, as time passes, she unexpectedly finds herself forming a bond with the burly pilot. But Calla is not in Alaska to stay, and Jonah will never leave. It would be foolish to kindle a romance, to take the same path her parents tried – and failed at – all those years ago.
When Jeanie’s aunt gifts her the beloved Pumpkin Spice Cafe in the small town of Dream Harbour, Jeanie leaps at the chance for a fresh start away from her very dull desk job. Logan is a local farmer who avoids Dream Harbour’s gossip at all costs. But Jeanie’s arrival disrupts Logan’s routine, and he wants nothing to do with the irritatingly upbeat new girl, except that he finds himself inexplicably drawn to her.
Will Jeanie’s happy-go-lucky attitude win over the grumpy-but-gorgeous Logan, or has this city girl found the one person in town who won’t fall for her charm, or her pumpkin spice lattes? Like Things We Never Got Over, The Pumpkin Spice Cafe is a cosy romantic tale featuring a grumpy/sunshine dynamic, a small-town setting, and plenty of found family themes!
Memphis Ward arrives in Quincy, Montana, on the fifth worst day of her life. Moving across the country with her newborn baby is the craziest thing she’s ever done. But maybe it takes a little crazy to build a good life. If putting the past behind her requires a thousand miles and a new town, she’s willing to do it. Even if it requires working as a housekeeper at The Eloise Inn and living in an apartment above a garage.
It’s there, on the fifth worst day of her life, that she meets the handsomest man she’s ever laid eyes on. Knox Eden is a beautiful, sinful dream, a chef, and a temporary landlord. With his sharp, stubbled jaw and tattooed arms, he’s raw and rugged and everything she’s never had – and never will. Because after the worst day of her life, Memphis learned a good life requires giving up on her dreams too. And a man like Knox can only ever be a dream.
Check Out The Best Lucy Score Books
Part-time reader, part-time rambler, and full-time Horror enthusiast, James has been writing for What We Reading since 2022. His earliest reading memories involved Historical Fiction, Fantasy and Horror tales, which he has continued to take with him to this day. James’ favourite books include The Last (Hanna Jameson), The Troop (Nick Cutter) and Chasing The Boogeyman (Richard Chizmar).
Her grandfather inspired Knives Out, now she's writing her own historical mysteries. Check out our…
Discover the most beautifully written sentences in literature. Explore iconic opening lines, poetic prose, and…
Wondering how many books you need to officially call your collection a library? From the…
Looking for your next psychological horror read? Read our Come Closer book review to discover…
Sprawling multi-generational epics, lyrical prose and forgotten heritages, check out the best books like There…
From women breaking their silence to characters ripping up social norms, check out the best…
This website uses cookies.